Configurations

PyPSA-Eur is able to provide the energy supply of an energy system given :

• The configuration of the system by year-varying parameters (such as carbon budget or primary route share in steel production) and fixed parameters (such as maximum potential per renewable technologies or charging power of EVs) ;

• The list of technologies used ;

• Techno-economic parameters (such as investment costs, efficiency, FOM, VOM, lifetime, discount rate, etc.).

The quality of the optimization results depends on the configuration quality, as :

• The evolution trajectory of year-dependent parameters has an impact on the energy demand (by dispatching the total demand over different vectors). Fixed parameters have an impact on some technologies (through potential, minimum capacity factor, etc.) ;

• The addition of a technology might lead to an energy system significantly cheaper throughout the optimization, due to otherwise non-existing or uninteresting interactions between technologies ;

• Some technologies might not be considered in the cost-optimal system because of too high CAPEX/OPEX, or might be massively installed because of too optimistic costs.

The way PyPSA deals with those different topics is explained in the following sections.

Technological assumptions

PyPSA-Eur optimization of the energy system is done by computing the cost-optimal sizing of each technology per geographical location.

A technology can be used for

• Generation of energy using energy carrier(s) to produce other energy carrier(s) :

  • i.e. Using coal to produce electricity, CO2 and captured CO2 for a coal powerplant with CC ;

  • i.e. Using hydrogen and captured CO2 to produce synthetic oil for the Fischer-Tropsh process;

• Storage of energy under a specific energy vector:

  • i.e. Centralized Thermal Energy Storage;

  • i.e. Hydrogen underground storage;

• Transmission of energy vector between two geographical locations:

  • i.e. AC and DC lines;

  • i.e. Methane pipelines;

  • i.e. CO2 pipelines.

Some technologies are added to the system only if an energy sector is considered in the optimization. An exhaustive list is given here below, sorted by module and with each energy carriers the technology uses.

Base technologies

Technology name	Carrier 1	Carrier 2	Carrier 3	Carrier 4
AC lines	Elec
Allam power cycle	Gas	Elec	CO2 CC
Ammonia storage	NH3
Ammonia cracker	Elec	NH3	H2
Battery storage	Elec battery
CCGT	Gas	Elec	CO2
CCGT CC	Gas	Elec	CO2	CO2 CC
CCGT H2	H2	Elec
CH4 (g) pipeline	Gas
CO2 pipeline	CO2 CC
CO2 sequestration	CO2 CC
Coal	Coal	Elec	CO2
Coal CC	Coal	Elec	CO2 CC	CO2
DC links	Elec (DC)	Elec
Electricity distribution grid	Elec	Elec (LV)
Electricity grid connection	Elec
Electrolysis	Elec	H2	(Central Heat)
Fuel cell	H2	Elec	(Central Heat)
H2 (g) pipeline	H2
H2 (g) pipeline repurposed	H2
Haber-Bosch	Elec	H2	NH3
Helmeth	Elec	CH4	CO2
Home battery storage	Elec battery
Hydro	Hydro	Elec
Hydrogen storage overground	H2
Hydrogen storage underground	H2
Lignite	Lignite	Elec
Methanation/Sabatier	H2	Gas	CO2
Nuclear	Uranium	Elec
OCGT	Gas	Elec	CO2
OCGT CC	Gas	Elec	CO2	CO2 CC
OCGT H2	H2	Elec
Offwind-AC	Wind	Elec
Offwind-DC	Wind	Elec
Onwind	Wind	Elec
PHS	Hydro	Elec
RoR	Hydro	Elec
SMR	Gas	H2	CO2
SMR CC	Gas	H2	CO2 CC	CO2
Solar utility	Solar	Elec
Solar rooftop	Solar	Elec
Oil	Oil	Elec	CO2

Heat technologies

Technology name	Carrier 1	Carrier 2	Carrier 3	Carrier 4
Central air-sourced heat pump	Elec	Heat buses
Central gas boiler	Gas	Heat buses
Central gas CHP	Gas	Elec	Heat buses
Central gas CHP CC	Gas	Elec	Heat buses	CO2 CC
Central ground-sourced heat pump	Elec	Heat buses
Central resistive heater	Elec	Heat buses
Central solar thermal	Heat buses
Central solid biomass CHP	Biomass	Elec	Heat
Central solid biomass CHP CC	Biomass	Elec	Heat	CO2 CC
Central water tank storage	Heat storage
Decentral air-sourced heat pump	Elec	Heat buses
Decentral gas boiler	Gas	Heat buses
Decentral ground-sourced heat pump	Elec	Heat buses
Decentral resistive heater	Elec	Heat buses
Decentral solar thermal	Heat buses
Decentral water tank storage	Heat storage
Direct air capture	CO2	CO2 CC	Elec	Urban heat
Micro CHP	Gas	Elec	Heat
Retrofitting	Retrofitting	Heat buses
Water tank charger	Heat storage	Heat buses
Water tank discharger	Heat storage	Heat buses

Biomass technologies

Technology name	Carrier 1	Carrier 2	Carrier 3	Carrier 4
Biogas	Biogas
Biogas upgrading	Biogas	Gas
Biomass boiler	Biomass	Heat
BioSNG	Biomass	Gas
BioSNG CC	Biomass	Gas	CO2 CC
BtL	Biomass	Oil
BtL CC	Biomass	Oil	CO2 CC
Central solid biomass CHP	Biomass	Elec	Heat
Central solid biomass CHP CC	Biomass	Elec	Heat	CO2 CC
Solid Biomass	Biomass

Biomass and Heat technologies

Technology name	Carrier 1	Carrier 2	Carrier 3	Carrier 4
Central solid biomass CHP	Biomass	Elec	Heat
Central solid biomass CHP CC	Biomass	Elec	Heat	CO2 CC

Industry technologies

Technology name	Carrier 1	Carrier 2	Carrier 3	Carrier 4
Ammonia load for ind	Ammonia
Biomass for ind	Biomass	Biomass for Ind
Biomass for ind CC	Biomass	Biomass for Ind	CO2 CC
Decentral oil boiler	Oil	Heat
Fischer-Tropsch	H2	Oil	(Central Heat)
Gas for ind	Gas	Gas for Ind
Gas for ind CC	Gas	Gas for Ind	CO2 CC
H2 liquefaction	H2	H2 liquid
Methanol load for ind	MeOH
Methanolisation	H2	MeOH	Elec
Oil boilers	oil	heat_buses (rural + urban decentral)
Process CO2 emissions	CO2 process
Process CO2 emissions CC	CO2 process	CO2 CC
Transport ship Methanol	H2	MeOH	Elec

Transport technologies

Technology name	Carrier 1	Carrier 2	Carrier 3	Carrier 4
V2G	EV	Elec
DSM	Elec	EV

Techno-economic parameters

The default definition of the technologies in PyPSA is done by retrieving data from a cost database and formatting it into the metrics used by PyPSA-Eur, namely :

• Annualized Capital cost (€/MW/year)

• Marginal cost (EUR/MWh)

• Lifetime (years)

• Efficiency(ies) (MWhout/MWhin)

• CO2 intensity (tCO2/MWhout)

• Potential (MWhmax)

• Carrier(s)

The cost database (pypsa/technology-data) has a granularity of up to 5 years and is mostly based on the Danish Energy Agency (DEA) forecasts (March 2018 - August 2023). The version v0.6.2 (PyPSA/technology-data) has been thoroughly reviewed by Climact and UGent to produce tailor-made files specific to each scenario considered.

It must be noted nonetheless that for some technologies, some techno-economic parameters are set from the configuration file instead of the cost database. Those values have been reviewed as well (see Configuration file).

Configuration file

PyPSA-Eur optimization is mostly based on the choice of the technologies used and the techno-economic parameters.

Some additional parameters can nonetheless be set from a separate configuration file. Those parameters can be grouped under different categories :

• On/off technology use : Levers (de)activating some technologies in PyPSA optimization

  • i.e. Conventional technologies to consider in future planning horizons;

  • i.e. Use of micro-CHP, solid biomass to liquid, etc.;

  • i.e. Considering distribution electric and/or gas networks;

• Technology parameters : techno-economic parameters that were not set from the cost database or that alter technologies

  • i.e. Potentials and correction factors for renewables;

  • i.e. Heat pump sink temperature;

• Demand-related parameters : share between different energy carriers of a given demand. They can be fixed over the explored time horizons or year-dependent

  • i.e. Share of primary route in steel production;

  • i.e. Share of EV/ICE/FC vehicles for land transport compared to today’s demand;

  • i.e. Share of HVC routes compared to today’s demand;

• Simulation parameters : parameters impacting the optimization constraints and energy system definition

  • i.e. Temporal scale for the system optimization

  • i.e. Carbon budget per year (how much CO2 can be emitted annually);

  • i.e. Authorized expansion of AC/DC transmission lines (in terms of cost or transmission capacity);

  • i.e. Regionalized/copperplated ammonia at EU scale;

  • i.e. Emission pricing and sequestration costs per tCO2;

  • i.e. Locations where hydrogen storage is allowed;

Those additional parameters default values can be modified to match expert’s best estimate.

Spatio-temporal specifications

PyPSA is technically able to define the energy supply down to a resolution of 1 hour and down to the spatial resolution of ENTSO-E transmission network. However, practically speaking, such a fine resolution (8760h on one year for ~8800 nodes) is not feasible due to the huge computational burden linked to the optimization of such an energy system.

The system is hence clustered to a smaller number of equivalent nodes (i.e. clusters), small enough to allow acceptable runtimes but large enough to ensure a detailed representation of the energy system (power demand, renewable power generation, transmission infrastructures, etc.).

As mentioned in [1], we need to be especially aware of the implications of those hypotheses. Model outputs are strongly influenced by network resolution. This is why we chose to take 37 clustered nodes into account while considering 181 renewables generation sites (onshore and offshore wind as well as utility-scale solar PV technologies). This gives a better estimation of the load factors for renewables without significantly increasing the computation time.

Temporal resolution has also been explored during the preliminary phase of the project. Two resolution techniques were proposed : time aggregation and time segmentation. Time aggregation averages timesteps on a given resolution (e.g.: 3h aggregation). Time segmentation use the tsam package (FZJ-IEK3-VSA/tsam). This package looks for typical periods using machine learning algorithms. While having an impact on the computation time, we preferred a 3h time aggregation to be as close as possible to profiles. This choice also eases the interpretation of results.

More details about the spatial resolution are given in Section Spatial resolution.